Dingzhou Wenzi Virtue

Some have named the Wenzi (Wen Tzu) the fourth most influential Daoist text after the Dao De JingZhuangzi, and Liezi. However, scholars have questioned its authenticity because it contains Confucianist, Legalist, and Mohist philosophies. In 1973, an early form of the Wenzi was discovered in Dingzhou, China (Creativity and Intertextuality, pages 8, 23, 25, 32, 61-65, 81, and 84).

Its teaching on virtue contradicts Daoist thought and is more consistent with a Confucianist approach.

Confucian Virtue

The Dingzhou Wenzi follows the Confucian teaching that a leader is the one who brings order to society.

It says a leader should possess the four qualities of virtue, compassion, propriety, and righteousness.

Under this hierarchical approach a leader should correct the people like a father corrects his children.

A leader is virtuous when they are not arrogant or heavy-handed.

If a leader remains virtuous, the people will enjoy success.

If a leader does not remain virtuous, the people will rebel or flee.

Daoist Virtue

Unlike Confucianism, a Daoist believes that a person does not need to deliberately try to be virtuous. This is because they automatically are by following the Dao. It is a byproduct of being in harmony with the Dao.

If a leader follows the Dao, then all things are taken care of and success follows. There is no need for a top down approach where a leader teaches propriety to the people. The leader simply gives people the freedom to follow the Dao themselves.

A leader does not need to correct the people because the people find their own harmony when they follow the Dao.

Conclusion

The Dingzhou Wenzi follows the Confucianist approach that a leader must be virtuous in order to have an ordered society. Under this hierarchical system, a leader must correct the people when they misbehave. This goes against Daoist teaching where one simply needs to follow the Dao and virtue and success follows. Under this more egalitarian approach a leader gives people the freedom to follow the Dao in their own lives and in doing so will find harmony.

Resources

The Wenzi: Creativity and Intertextuality in Early Chinese Philosophy (Studies in the History of Chinese Texts, 9), Paul Van Els, Brill Academic Publisher, 2018. Quotes taken from this source found on pages 26, 50, 69-70, 89-92

Els, P. van. (2006, May 29). The Wenzi: creation and manipulation of a Chinese
philosophical text. Retrieved from https://hdl.handle.net/1887/4428.

Liezi Chapter 7: Yang Zhu

The Liezi is considered the third most important text in Daoism (Taoism) after the Dao De Jing and Zhuangzi. Chapter seven is named Yang Zhu and focuses on living in the moment.

Reputation, fame, and status

The sage does not worry about external factors such as reputation, fame, or status.

They know that reputation does not reflect reality. One may live generously but only have a good reputation after they die. One may live indulgently, but have a bad reputation after they die.

Fame and status are also artificial and have no lasting benefit.

Wealth

The sage knows that striving for wealth makes one unfulfilled.

The physical body is also a possession which one should not become attached.

It doesn’t matter if one values life, they will still die at their natural time. There is no point in worrying about death.

Worrying about a long life, fame, status, or wealth causes unneeded stress.

The future

The sage does not concern themselves with the future.

They don’t concern themselves with what happens after death.

Emptiness

The sage focuses on the internal by seeking a state of emptiness. This allows one to be a peace with the world.

They cultivate humility, generosity, and compassion.

Present moment

The sage finds contentment in the present moment.

The sage knows that the present moment is precious and fleeting.

Conclusion

The sage does not worry about the external. Reputation, status, fame and wealth are all artificial and leaves one unfulfilled. They do not concern themselves with the future because it creates unneeded anxiety.

Instead the sage focuses on the internal and seeks a state of emptiness. They are humble, generous, and compassionate and find contentment in savoring the present moment. One should surround themselves with pleasant sounds, environments, smells, and express themselves freely.

Resource

The Book of Master Lie, Thomas Cleary, translator. 2011. A nice translation of Liezi.

Liezi Chapter 6: Effort and Destiny

The Liezi is considered the third most important text in Daoism (Taoism) after the Dao De Jing and Zhuangzi. Chapter six is named Effort and Destiny and explores the impact of the Dao on our lives.

Success and Failure

A “sage” is one who lives their life according to the virtue of the Dao.

They view the Dao as destiny and the way of nature. They know that things such as success and failure are based on the flow of nature and often out of their control.

One should go along with nature just as farmers follow the seasons. A farmer might have a successful year based on the weather like a person might have a successful year based on the flow of the Dao.

Life and Death

The sage recognizes that life and death are beyond their control. One doesn’t choose when they are born or when they die.

One may die even if they value life. One may live even if they hate life.

People live their natural length of years and eventually the younger generation takes their place.

Leadership

A leader who follows the Dao forgives the mistakes of others. They do not engage in endless blaming of others.

A true leader is compassionate and inspires others. They are trusted by their superiors.

A leader does not bully or criticize others. They know that this would be counterproductive and lead to a backlash.

They never command others and always remain humble.

Conclusion

The Dao can be seen as nature or destiny. It is best to flow with nature because success and failure, life and death, are often out of a person’s control. A leader acting in accordance with the Dao forgives others, is compassionate and inspirational. They are trusted, never bully others, and remain humble.

Resource

The Book of Master Lie, Thomas Cleary, translator. 2011. A nice translation of Liezi.

Compassion

The Dao De Jing (Tao Te Ching) outlines how one can live in accordance with the “Way” of the universe. Compassion is considered one of the three treasure of the Dao (Tao). Those with compassion will succeed in life and become strong. They will win in conflict and be able to defend themselves.

Taking Care of Others

A wise person makes sure that others don’t feel alone and isolated. Having compassion for others means making sure that all people have what they need.

Being Good to All

Compassion means being good to those who are not good. One should be faithful to those who are not faithful. Compassion gives the virtue of faithfulness and sincerity (Dao De Ching, Chapter 49).

Protecting the Weak

Compassion allows one to see the small and protect the weak. In this way using compassion is following the Tao and will benefit both you and others (Tao Te Ching, Chapter 52).

Conclusion

Compassion is a treasure that will allow one to succeed in life and be protected. It involves protecting others and making sure no one is discarded. Compassion can also be challenging because it requires one to be good to those who are not good.