Zhuangzi Chapter 17: Autumn Floods

The book Zhuangzi is an essential text in Daoism. Chapter Seventeen, Fit for Emperors and Kings, describes having an expansive perspective on life and seeing the unity of all things. The sage seeks emptiness and sees that there is truly no division between life and death, right and wrong, or past and present. This chapter differs significantly from the inner chapters because it focuses on one long conversation between the Yellow River and the North Sea.

Pride

During the Autumn floods, streams poured into the Yellow River making it overflow its banks. The Lord of the River was full of pride at how powerful he had become. However, when he made it to the North Sea he became humbled by its vastness.

Perspective

Ruo of the North Sea was so vast that it gave the Yellow River a more expansive perspective. He realized that he had been so vain. This is a common occurrence with many not seeing the big picture. A frog in the well can’t understand the ocean. An insect in the summer has no conception of winter. A scholar locked into their own beliefs can’t understand the Way.

Large v. Small

This expanded perspective also means that size doesn’t matter. A small amount of time is just as important as a large. A near place as important as a far place. Short as meaningful as long.

Past v. Present

With this expanded perspective, one realizes that there is no division between past and present. Time is connected and flows on unceasingly.

Life and Death

Because time always continues, death need not be feared. The time a person is alive does not compare to the time before they were born.

Life has a natural rhythm in which all things progress. They are born, grow, decay, and finally die.

Right v. Wrong

One with proper perspective realizes that both right and wrong are subjective and vary from society to society. What is considered right in one culture is wrong in another.

Usefulness

Expanding perspective helps the sage understand that nothing is truly useless. Usefulness depends on the point of view of the individual.

Usefulness also depends on the specific circumstances of the situation. Somethings will work in certain situations but not others. A beam can be used to break a wooden door, but not to plug up a small hole.

All beings have different needs. The frog is happy in a small well while the great turtle is happiest in the wide sea.

The sage realizes that all act according to their nature. The millipede moves with ten thousand legs while the snake moves using its backbone. The wind moves without any physical form.

Harmony

If one has an expansive perspective they see the connection of all things. The sage seeks harmony and balance. They do not harm others, yet don’t flaunt their pacifism. They do not seek profit but don’t condemn others for doing so. They do not accumulate possessions, yet don’t brag about their un-attachment. They do not ask for help, but don’t tout their self sufficiency. They do not seek fame, but do not judge others that do. They live simply with what has been given to them.

In a state of harmony one can tell the difference between safety and danger. One can accept both fortune and misfortune. In this way the sage does not allow negative circumstances to harm them because they don’t see them as negative. They are simply part of the up and downs of life.

Nature v. Humanity

The sage follows the way of nature and not the way of humanity. Nature gives us life, physical form, and a set of skills and limitations. Humanity gives us culture and rules.

The sage does not allow human values such as fame and desire to keep one away from following their own nature.

Success Depends on Circumstances

The sage recognizes that circumstances play an oversized role in success or failure. Often one has to be at the right time and place to be successful.

Refuse Responsibility

The sage is not interested in power or leadership. They refuse such roles and stick to the way of nature.

Conclusion

The sage seeks an expanded perspective viewing the unity of all things. There is no real division between large and small, past and present, right and wrong, or life and death. Life simply follows the rhythm of birth, aging, and death. Nothing is truly useless. All beings have different needs according to their nature. The sage seeks harmony and follows the way of nature and not the way of humanity which includes power, pride, and fame.

Zhuangzi Chapter 4: In the World of Men

Master Zhuang is the second most influential writer in Daoism (Taoism) and the book Zhuangzi was named after him. Chapter Four is In the World of Men and teaches how to reform someone without virtue.

Reforming One without Virtue

The Zhuangzi used historical figures such as Confucius to teach about the Dao. Yan Hui asked Confucius for permission to go to Wei to reform a violent ruler. Confucius advised against going, warning that he likely would be killed.

If he was fortunate enough not to be executed, he would probably still fail. Rulers are experts at bringing others to their side and can convince others to support them. Besides, one should be sure they have virtue in themselves before you try to reform others.

Yan Hui asked if he could reform the ruler by being resolute. Confucius responded that the ruler may make outward signs of reform but would never truly do so.

Not giving up easily, Yan Hui suggested outwardly agreeing with the ruler but remaining inwardly resolute. He could quote the words of historical teachers. Confucius responded, that he may avoid punishment, but would still not convert the tyrant.

The Daoist Approach

The Daoist approach to reform others is to be resolute inwardly and follow your own way. Don’t be motivated by fame or look for personal gain. Forget ego and be in a state of emptiness. Give the person advice only if they are willing to listen, otherwise remain silent.

Yan He wanted to reform the prince of Wei. Ju Boyu advised him to support the prince’s actions outwardly, but to be careful not to get drawn into his actions so much as be condemned by others.

The Ambassador

Ambassador Zigao of She asked Confucius for advice on his upcoming mission. Confucius reminded Zigao of the two great decrees: the duty to parents and to the nation. However, the greatest virtue is not to allow outside factors to affect your personal way and accept that there are things that you can not change.

Confucius went on to give advice on being a messenger. A messenger feels pressure to please both sides by exaggerating the positives. Exaggeration is irresponsible and reduces credibility. Inaccurate words can put the messenger in danger.

The messenger should never go beyond their orders or press too hard for agreement. A lasting agreement takes time and a bad agreement is hard to change. One should accept what you can’t change and focus on your own personal way.

Usefulness

Trees feature prominently in Daoist thought. The carpenter Shi went to Qui and saw an enormous oak tree with its lowest branches 80 feet off the ground. He called the tree worthless because it could not be used for timber, boats, or doors. Shi had a dream where the Oak tree visited saying it was not useless because it sheltered hundreds of people. Besides, “useful” trees do not get to live out their normal lifespan because they are cut down prematurely.

In a similar episode, Ziqi of Nanbo saw a large tree in which thousands of horses could take shelter. Even though its gnarled and pitted limbs made it “useless” as timber, it was used by Holy Men for gatherings.

A disabled man named Shu had a twisted body and could not stand straight. He survived by washing other people’s clothes and getting handouts. In-spite of his physical disabilities he got by and lived out his normal years. He avoided conscription by the army and his physical disability paled in comparison to a disability of virtue.

Finally, Jie Yu was called the madman of Chu because he would cry out in public that the past was gone and the future would never arrive. The sage succeeds with the Dao and simply survives without it. No one can truly know the usefulness of something.

Conclusion

Trying to reform others can be dangerous and lead to failure. One must be sure in their own virtue before reforming others. The best approach is to be inwardly resolute and following your own personal way. Don’t be motivated by fame and only give advice if the other person is willing to listen.

A messenger should never exaggerate or press for an agreement. Twisted trees may appear useless but often have an unforeseen purpose living out its normal years. Twisted virtue is much worse than having a twisted body.

Zhuangzi Chapter 1: Free and Easy Wandering

Master Zhuang is the second most influential writer in Daoism (Taoism) and the book Zhuangzi was named after him. Chapter One is entitled Free and Easy Wandering and challenges our normal definition of usefulness. How useful a thing is depends on the sizes involved, lifespan, and purpose.

Usefulness Based on Size

Usefulness depends on the relative sizes involved. There was a bird who measured a thousand miles wide and flew for nine months straight. It found the wind very useful in order to fly long distances. There was a small cicada and dove who could barely fly to the next tree. They did not find the wind useful because they only traveled a few yards. A massive gourd was useless to carry water because it became too heavy, but it could be used as a boat to float down a river.

Usefulness Based on Lifespan

Usefulness is dependent on the lifespan involved. The morning mushroom does not see the twilight, the summer cicada does not see the spring. What was useful for these short lived beings are not useful to longer lived ones such as humans or animals.

Usefulness Based on Purpose

Usefulness also depends on the purpose a thing. A family had a secret recipe for chapped hands ointment and used it when bleaching silk in water. Over generations, they never made much money. They eventually sold the recipe to a traveler who gave it to soldiers to help them hold weapons during a battle. The army won and the king rewarded the traveler with much land. A gnarled and twisted tree may be worthless to a carpenter but may be perfect to provide shade. The same item is useless for one purpose but has much use for another.

Lesson for the Individual

Our personal circumstances often make it hard to see what is important in life. The small dove can’t understand why another would want to fly hundreds of miles because the dove only needs to travel a few yards. We often put significant value on our accomplishments even when they are relatively small. The dove may have an outsized pride in traveling just a few yards. A person shouldn’t take pride in their own accomplishments such as gaining fame, wealth, or power. The Daoist would say the individual shouldn’t be bothered by such things, but be content in finding usefulness in the everyday things around them.

Conclusion

Master Zhuang recognizes that usefulness is subjective to the time, space, and purpose. What may be useful for a large creature is not useful for a small one. What is useful for a long lived creature is not useful to a short lived one. Sometimes usefulness can be found by shifting the perspective of how to use a thing. At first it may seem worthless but it may just be looking for the right purpose. The individual should not find value in pride, fame, and power. Instead they should be content in finding usefulness all around them.

Resource

Complete Works Of Chuang Tzu, Burton Watson, translator. Columbia University Press, 1968. A good and classic translation of Chuang Tzu.